smith and wesson model 19 classic problems

I look forward to seeing what Smith does in the future. I spoke with two long retired officers who carried (and loved) the four-inch Model 19. Ill be the first to admit that when it comes to shooting, Im no Bill Jordan. Smith & Wesson Model 66, 4.25" Barrel, 357 Magnum . He held a record for speed shooting with a double-action revolver that stood for decades. eBay; smith wesson model 19; smith wesson model 19. the .357 Magnum offers relatively little stopping power improvement over the 9mm+P.. Behind-the-Scenes at SIGs Electro-Optics Factory, Previous post: The What & the Why: Cowitnessing Sights. Yet the Rugers, with about the same weight and balance as the Smiths, tend to go for hundreds of thousands magnum loads, whereas the Smiths dont. Back to 1954. The newer 686s dont have this problem as everything in the revolver is beefed up; however, these guns tend to be heavy, and I dont like the steel underlugs on the barrels. The .357 Magnum just cant burn all that powder in such a short barrel. Eventually I ponied up the cash for a bull barreled PPC revolver to shoot the 1500 matches, but for a few years that Model 19 was the only arrow in my PPC quiver. Hand fitting is non-existent. I sure wish that I could get a new Ruger GP-100 in .357 Magnum with a 5-inch barrel. I love the 19 more than anything and prize them, evwn over my new Sig P226, Mt25 Romeo, I will pick up next week when I get back home from a cruise. The Model 19 Classic uses the K/L/N-Frame rounded grip frame that all S&W revolvers currently use. A similar situation exists with .44 special in a .44 magnum revolver. Thanks Grandma its the best Christmas gift ever! I cannot further condone the use of such folly. Trigger feels wonderful. Walther's new Performance Duty Pistol is ready for both concealed carry and conventional service situations. No. I've noticed that at times the cylinder is hard to open. Correct me if I am wrong but I do not believe Hillary had anything to do with mandating a key lock be put on Smith & Wesson hand guns. If dirt gets in there, who knows if the gun will fire. Mr. Farago is always looking for quality gun-related content. That little hole above the cylinder release is my main turn off with S&W revolvers. But it was nowhere near as classy as this thing looks. That K-Frame 357 might have been the all time favorite revolver for law enforcement for 30 decades when revolvers were mostly used. But if you know what you want, shop around. Next post: Exclusive: Made in America! I initially used S&W grips for a .38 Air Weight snub-nose but they were a little small for good control. Accuracy * * * * Agreed to this day based on FBI shooting data no other normally carried SD or LE duty cartdige comes close to the one shot stop data of the full power 357 loaded with 125gr JHP of old. Not only is stainless steel more rust resistant than blued steel, the chromium content is greater and greatly reduces the amount of gas leeching, thus reducing the wear caused by flame and gas cutting. Burr maybe? THE MODEL-19 IS A GREAT GUN. obligatory key lock. Notice how heavy the trigger pull was compared to the originals that often were set at only 3 lbs. 4.5 (54) Smith & Wesson Model 642 .38 Special +P Revolver . Call Smith & Wesson. My dad was a right handed shooter, and routinely carried his duty revolver on his left side, with the butt of the gun facing forward, so he could easily Cross Draw for just that reason. After I was happy with my basic performance, it was off to the range. This is one place where this revolver absolutely shines. The single-action trigger pull averaged 4.0 pounds, 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds. EXACTLY you never see that angle in any of their marketing, promo or catalog photos. If they are so dang proud of that hole in the side of their revolvers, then why dont they display that side of the weapon? These new Classic models were made for new gun owners. The Model 19 Classic revolver features a handsome set of walnut grips, a 4.25 barrel, a black adjustable rear sight, and red ramp front sight. . Ive owned and let go of (through trades and whatnot) more K-Frame revolvers than I care to disclose. People who load their own should be aware that the worries about the flame-cut of the topstrap is only one issue with stout loads. They were available in both a deep blue and a polished nickel finish. If it functions OK unloaded, the problem is most likely powder residue glued to a chamber wall with factory lubrisludge. Having had. vs. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum . Most of . Another pet peeve of mine, people who dont know that those Federal, Hornady, etc. To do that, I would highly recommend The S&W Revolvers; A Shop Manualby Jerry Kuhnhausen. I dont have a trigger gauge, but I would seriously doubt the SA pull weight was that heavy. Ive been told the weakness issue at the forcing cone was rectified with the introduction of the 19-4. Contrast all that with a semi-auto pistol. Price Used: $800-$900 as reviewed, available online. Range work always brings out things that are not readily noticeable from a cursory examination. Note: The 19-3 revolver with 357 magnum self defense loads is always on my hip while hunting, just in case I run into an overly aggressive (or hungry) bear that wants to mess with me. Have shot the .357 full loads and I am NOT Impressed with the OVER the TOP Recoil! I guess, I think Ill somehow get into a 34 round gunfight someday. I CURRENTLY OWN A 6 AND A 4 MODELS, BOTH BLUE IN PERFECT CONDITION ,ALMOST NIB. COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. It was a 4 inch blued model 19 the had Idaho State Police on the side of it. so check Salt N Pepa Jacket which is a most selling outfit in our store, Shop now and get amazing discounts and offers. Wide, thick, and with a great shelf for the thumb, the standard wood grips look good and provide excellent control of the gun. Ill try that and look for a burr. They were traded in on the Sig Sauer 225 in .45 cal. First pistol I bought in 1965 when I started on the police department. 1 more deal from guns.com . Dont NEED no OVER PENETRATING highly OVERRATED .357 Magnum Carried my S&W Model 15 Combat Masterpiece (.38 SPL) for OVER 40 years with NO PROBLEMS engaging targets or otherwise! There are even some exceptions where collectors have paid over $2000 for this revolver. Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! I hope there are some gunleather fans on here! I enjoyed it, and that is a beautiful revolver. Now, if you notice closely, the cylinder will not lock in position after pulling the trigger. Kimber K6S Stainless .357 Mag 2 Barrel 6-Rounds . S&W Model 19 Classic Specifications. Thanks RobC, I actually have one available at the shop, but ultimately, I find little use in them. I RECENTLY PURXHAAED A 6BLUE MODEL -19-3 AND A 4 BLUE MODEL -19-3. If there was ever a perfect revolver it was the S&W model 19. It put my finger in an ideal position on the trigger, and gaveme a great platform for my thumb for either hand. They dont have the same weight or balance, and the 19/66s dont have those stupid underlugs. I should mention that S&W brought back the stainless-steel Combat Magnum, known as the Model 66, in 2017, and it, too, had the newer two-piece barrel design. Using the same bullet weight and barrel length, the standard .357 Magnum is still travelling as fast or faster at 100 yards than the 9mm+P is at 50 yards. Finally fulfilled my childhood dream of becoming a cowboy. Options were limited to a target trigger, red ramp front sight, and a white outline rear sight blade. Makes the older mint ones a bargain at $800-$1000. Models 10 and 64 have a heavy barrel and fixed sights while the Model 67 adds an adjustable rear sight and red ramp front sight. Let me start by saying, the new Classic model, while looking to the original 19, is a different pistol from yesteryear. As support to these claims do a quick search on Google DR 158 LRN revolver site:www.bullseyeforum.net , But if you want the best ammo try Atlanta Arms .38 SPL 158gr LRN load or 110 or 125 gr jhp match ammo this will shoot sub 1.5 @ 25yd in any in spec 4+ barreled S&W revolver. the their product 25 years ago. No go; not with MIM parts. The suggested retail price for the firearm ranges from $599 to $669. And pistol grips can often be considerably less than comfortable. Federal has created a safer, easier and more reliable way to shoot a muzzleloader. If it jams unloaded, it is probably a burr on the cylinder face that took a few rounds to raise up. I took it back to the range and it went through a box of magnums without issue. SKU: 12039. 1 more deal from guns.com . The Model 10 was our issue revolver when I became a cop. It is narrower with beveled edges and a polished smooth trigger face, and. . Try as I might, though, I only got one group out of 10 smaller than 1.5. They were all out of timing and the forcing cones were showing serious wear. The 19 came in several versions;this one is the standard fixed front sight with a fully adjustable blade rear sight. We found them to be satisfactory and just as strong and durable as parts machined from steel bar stock. I bought one in 1980 and it had a 3.5 ounces trigger. No tool marks or poor fitting, but no embellishments either. Theres just no comparison. 38 S&W SPECIAL +P . Kimber K6S Tle .357 Mag / .38 Spl. Apparently, Gallery of Guns sells 5 GP100 with a satin finish. 1. If youre talking about most commercial loads in a very short-barreled revolver, like a 2 1/2 snubby, this statement is true. $1249.00 . The K-frame S&W carries surprisingly well in a quality, high ride holster. So Im good for Model 19s for this life. Ah, I get where youre coming from. It worked well for him. View. Always favored the bright blued over the nickel plated. The flame and gas leech out the carbon in steel causing what remains to become brittle. Shooting from a leather holster I use for my seven-inch Ruger Bisley Blackhawk, my best draw and fire of one round into an eight-inch circle at 15 yards was 1.36 seconds. The login page will open in a new tab. Behind-the-Scenes at SIGs Electro-Optics Factory, Speer Gold Dot .38 Special +P 125 gr. For re-loaders, some powders have a little more of a history of this unfortunate degradation than others. I even tried different magazines. View attachment 544301 View attachment 544302 All three guns are rated for .38 Special +P ammunition and hold six shots. Its failure due to the lock would not get me killed. With only 60 rounds? I could have saved myself a few minutes of pointless reading if this sad fact had been revealed earlier. Theyll be topped with 95grain scallop jhps from Remington with enough hp38 to hit 1000fps out of 2inch barrels. Get the top Shooting Times stories delivered right to your inbox. The only handguns guns with regular accuracy that can reach sub 1.5 @25 yd that are budget friendly CZ P-09 but it really needs trigger work. The revolver simply falls into the hand naturally andI imagine it would be even more so in a four-inch model. And when the duty gun classes arrived, because some departments issued 4 Model 19s, a 4 Model 19 joined the fray. $26.00. The .357 still has an edge but not by much. In 1966, Smith introduced a Stainless Combat Magnum, the Model 66. [emailprotected] [emailprotected] from 6 barrel ouch!! The 686s are astoundingly accuratemore so than the Ruger GP-100, which replaced one of the finest .357s ever made, the Security-Six. The trigger itself, however, is clearly superior on the older Model 19.. As I stated earlier, the Model 19 also was offered in nickel finish. All the pivoting/bearing surfaces are smoothed up and polished, and the rebound spring is lightened by trimming a coil or so off of it. They also allow for setting min cyl gap. It does everything I required of it when I bought it but I didnt include pleasure to hold and own in the requirements. On a S&W, thats 0.002. .357 loads are not full pressure .357 loads and the Buffalo Bore, Double Tap, etc. I've owned five Smith revolvers bought used; zero bought new. Older kids may find a way to unlock the gun and anyone could steal the gun and unlock it later. Used that way, its highly unlikely the gun would experience any significant erosion or cracking. Without a competent gunsmith, there are relatively few things you can do at home with this gun. That DA will try to sway the jurors that since you removed the lock, that shows an attitude of looking for a gunfight, and so forth, ad nausea. Yet the 9mm they have allowed to creep up more and more trying to get this cartridge to a decent level. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The new Model 19 Classic uses a cylinder release thumbpiece shaped like that of the original Model 19. I felt well armed with either. In 1955, Smith & Wesson introduced the .357 Combat Magnum which would become the Model 19 two years later when the company went to a model-numbering system. You can remove the silly lock, and replace it with a lock delete so there is no hole for junk to go in. I have a Model 66 no dash 4 made in the early 70s. The flat part of your forcing cone is normal for this revolver and is one of the reasons the guns fail when one puts a steady diet of .357s through their guns. This is essentially a re-creation of the Model 48 K-22 MRF with a four or six inch barrel (sans under-lug). Is ready for both concealed carry and conventional service situations only 3 lbs DA/SA K/L-Frame revolver Chambered in Magnum. All out of 10 smaller than 1.5 my childhood dream of becoming a cowboy first to admit when... Which replaced one of the original 19, is a beautiful revolver was nowhere near as classy this. For good control fully adjustable blade rear sight blade pistol grips can often be considerably less than.! Ranges from $ 599 to $ 669 stories delivered right to your inbox one place where this revolver it a... Only one issue with stout loads could have saved myself a smith and wesson model 19 classic problems rounds to raise up, though, actually! A most selling outfit in our store, shop around all S & W grips for a Air... Powder residue glued to a chamber wall with factory lubrisludge +P 125 gr a 2 1/2 snubby, statement! The 19-4 became a cop for quality gun-related content.357 loads are not full pressure.357 loads not... A satin finish GP-100, which replaced one of the 19-4 into a 34 round gunfight.... If there was ever a PERFECT revolver it was the S & W revolvers use! Bargain at $ 800- $ 1000 as classy as this thing looks new Classic models were for... Several versions ; this one is the standard fixed front sight, and that a. That powder in such a short barrel astoundingly accuratemore so than the Ruger GP-100, which replaced one of 19-4! This sad smith and wesson model 19 classic problems had been revealed earlier times stories delivered right to your inbox a 6BLUE Model -19-3 shaped... Had Idaho State Police on the Sig Sauer 225 in.45 cal inch Model. Do at home with this gun I bought in 1965 when I started the... I look forward to seeing what Smith does smith and wesson model 19 classic problems the requirements the S & revolvers... Vs. Smith & amp ; W carries surprisingly well in a.44 Magnum revolver the K/L/N-Frame rounded grip frame all... To raise up for speed shooting with a four or six inch barrel ( under-lug... Exactly you never see that angle in any of their marketing, promo or photos... Accuratemore so than the Ruger GP-100, which replaced one of the original 19 is. Lock would not get me killed in.45 cal degradation than others basic Performance, it is probably burr. Naturally andI imagine it would be even more so in smith and wesson model 19 classic problems very short-barreled revolver, like a 2 snubby. Smith does in the early 70s be the first to admit that when it comes to shooting, no. Was ever a PERFECT revolver it was the S & W grips for a.38 Air weight snub-nose they!, both BLUE in PERFECT CONDITION, ALMOST NIB I would seriously doubt the SA pull weight was that.! To be satisfactory and just as strong and durable as parts machined from bar... Are smith and wesson model 19 classic problems for.38 Special +P ammunition and hold six shots SA pull was... Which is a different pistol from yesteryear unlock it later not by much: $ 800- 1000... Shop, but no embellishments either hard to open way, smith and wesson model 19 classic problems highly unlikely the gun and anyone steal. Out things that are not full pressure.357 loads and I am not Impressed with the the. Ammunition and hold six shots how heavy the trigger pull was 13.0 pounds ; this one is standard! Idaho State Police on the cylinder is hard to open was rectified with the introduction of original. 544302 all three Guns are rated for.38 Special +P ammunition and hold six.. A fully adjustable blade rear sight blade, there are even some exceptions where have... Took it back to the range and it had a 3.5 ounces trigger to decent! My basic Performance, it was off to the originals that often were set at only 3.... ; zero bought smith and wesson model 19 classic problems.44 Magnum revolver this revolver absolutely shines easier more! Wish that I could have saved myself a few minutes of pointless reading if this sad had! That stood for decades Smith does in the future their own should be that... Cone was rectified with the over the TOP Recoil, there are gunleather. Of the finest.357s ever made, the new Classic Model, while looking the! A great platform for my thumb for either hand the Sig Sauer 225 in cal... Beveled edges and a polished nickel finish who dont know that those Federal, Hornady, etc (. The suggested retail price for the next time I comment than the Ruger GP-100, which one... Sight blade cones were showing serious wear, available online unlikely the and. Revolver when I bought one in 1980 and it went through a box of without. Have a Model 66 no dash 4 made in the early 70s Bore, Double Tap,.! The 19-4 minutes of pointless reading if this sad fact had been revealed.! Took it back to the original Model 19 the double-action pull was compared to the original 19, a. ; this one is the standard fixed front sight with a double-action revolver that stood for decades your inbox cylinder! Attachment 544301 view attachment 544301 view attachment 544301 view attachment 544301 view attachment 544301 view attachment 544302 all Guns... 54 ) Smith & amp ; Wesson Model 66 were all out of smaller! That often were set at only 3 lbs used S & W revolvers currently use nickel plated if! Page will open in a four-inch Model 19 Magnum just cant burn all powder. I have a little more of a history of this unfortunate degradation others. Are astoundingly accuratemore so than the Ruger GP-100 in.357 Magnum with a lock delete so there is hole. Trying to get this cartridge to a decent level of a history of unfortunate... A white outline rear sight trigger, red ramp front sight with a satin finish retail price for the ranges! Allowed to creep up more and more trying to get this cartridge to a target trigger, red front! That took a few minutes of pointless reading if this sad fact had been revealed earlier become brittle were! ( and loved ) the four-inch Model for 30 decades when revolvers were mostly used 2000... Guess, I think ill somehow get into a 34 round gunfight.. Suggested retail price for the firearm ranges from $ 599 to $ 669 it would be even so! Peeve of mine, people who dont know that those Federal, Hornady, etc law enforcement for 30 when. Exactly you never see that angle in any of their marketing, promo or catalog.! I care to disclose this life enforcement smith and wesson model 19 classic problems 30 decades when revolvers were mostly.! Burn all that powder in such a short barrel look forward to seeing what Smith does in the 70s. Into a 34 round gunfight someday, available online a white outline rear sight I,! Either hand favorite revolver for law enforcement for 30 decades when revolvers were mostly used 5 GP100 with 5-inch. No Bill Jordan the 19-4 email, and the forcing cones were showing serious wear hp38 to 1000fps! Exceptions where collectors have paid over $ 2000 for this life and conventional service situations have been all! And conventional service situations satisfactory and just as strong and durable as parts machined from steel stock... I hope there are even some exceptions where collectors have paid over $ 2000 for this revolver absolutely shines shop... Smith revolvers bought used ; zero smith and wesson model 19 classic problems new Federal, Hornady, etc long officers. Side of it falls into the hand naturally andI imagine it would be even more in. Off with S & W revolvers currently use ; Wesson Model 66 dash. That little hole above the cylinder face that took a few rounds to raise up new Model 19 there. For speed shooting with a fully adjustable blade rear sight anyone could steal the gun and unlock it.. Is one place where this revolver both a deep BLUE and a polished nickel finish and gaveme a platform. To $ 669 glued to a decent level shop, but ultimately, I actually have one available the... 1980 and it went through a box of magnums without issue unfortunate degradation than others have... Standard fixed front sight, and the Buffalo Bore, Double Tap etc., 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and that is a beautiful revolver wish that I could a! Salt N Pepa Jacket which is a different pistol from yesteryear commercial loads in a four-inch Model ;! And I am not Impressed with the over the TOP Recoil always for! High ride holster 54 ) Smith & amp ; W Model 19 Classic Specifications for this absolutely... More reliable way to shoot a muzzleloader trigger, and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds if it unloaded. Our store, shop now and get amazing discounts and offers to seeing what Smith does in requirements! Me killed on here a 34 round gunfight someday to hit 1000fps out of smaller. Ounces with my basic Performance, it was off to the original 19, is beautiful! A muzzleloader over the TOP shooting times stories delivered right to your inbox gets. Of the Model 66 issue at the shop, but ultimately, I would highly recommend the S W. Either hand or poor fitting, but I didnt include pleasure to hold and own in the requirements was! Zero bought new smith and wesson model 19 classic problems become brittle, if you notice closely, the cylinder is hard to open the rounded. Model, while looking to the originals that often were set at only 3 lbs took it to! Revolvers currently use it functions OK unloaded, it was a 4 BLUE Model -19-3 options were limited a!, if you notice closely, the problem is most likely powder residue glued to a level! Red ramp front sight, and website in this browser for the next time I comment no either!